Caribbean All-Inclusive Holidays: Which Island Is Best for You?
Caribbean all-inclusive holidays are among the most popular ways for UK travellers to experience the region’s beaches, food, and culture with complete ease. With flights to the Caribbean becoming increasingly accessible and year-round sunshine across the islands, all-inclusive packages offer exceptional value and convenience for couples, families, and solo travellers.
But with more than 30 islands offering all-inclusive resorts, the question most travellers ask is simple: which Caribbean island is best for my holiday?
Every island offers something different. Some are ideal for luxury escapes with private beaches and gourmet dining. Others are perfect for families, adventure lovers, or travellers looking to reconnect with Caribbean heritage.
This guide breaks down the top islands for all-inclusive holidays in the Caribbean, helping you choose the destination that matches your style, budget, and expectations.
Why Choose an All-Inclusive Holiday in the Caribbean?
All-inclusive holidays offer several advantages that make them perfect for travellers seeking simplicity and value:
• Upfront budgeting with no surprise costs
• Meals, drinks, activities, and entertainment included
• Access to private beaches and resort facilities
• Ideal for families who want flexibility and space
• Excellent value when travelling during shoulder seasons
• Options ranging from luxury adults-only escapes to family-friendly resorts
For travellers booking flights to the Caribbean from the UK, an all-inclusive package can also help simplify travel arrangements by bundling flights, transfers, and accommodation.
Best Caribbean Islands for All-Inclusive Holidays
Barbados: For Culture, Food, and Refined Luxury
Barbados strikes the perfect balance between relaxation and culture. With calm beaches on the west coast, lively areas in St Lawrence Gap, and world-class rum, it offers a well-rounded Caribbean experience.
Why choose Barbados:
• Some of the region’s most polished all-inclusive resorts
• Stable year-round weather and low hurricane risk
• Excellent dining, from gourmet restaurants to local fish markets
• Famous west-coast beaches with clear, calm waters
• Easy access to cultural attractions, markets, and rum distilleries
Barbados is perfect for couples and travellers looking for a refined, safe, and culturally rich island.
St Lucia: For Romance, Scenery, and Adventure
St Lucia is the Caribbean’s most dramatic island, combining rainforest mountains, volcanic beaches, and boutique resorts with private plunge pools.
Why choose St Lucia:
• Extraordinary scenery including the Pitons
• High-end all-inclusive options geared toward couples
• Activities such as hiking, zip-lining, hot springs, and boat tours
• Diverse coastline with both peaceful bays and livelier beaches
Travellers seeking a honeymoon, romantic escape, or a holiday with a strong focus on nature will find St Lucia compelling.
Jamaica: For Music, Culture, Nightlife, and Value
Jamaica is one of the Caribbean’s largest islands, offering an unbeatable mix of food, music, waterfalls, and excellent all-inclusive value. Its variety means travellers can choose between quiet, laid-back resorts or vibrant areas with nightlife.
Why choose Jamaica:
• Outstanding value for all-inclusive holidays
• Rich culture, reggae heritage, and warm hospitality
• Larger resorts with wide-ranging entertainment
• Famous attractions such as Dunn’s River Falls and Blue Lagoon
With regular flights to Montego Bay and Kingston, Jamaica is ideal for families, couples, or groups wanting a lively, authentic Caribbean experience.
Antigua: For Beach Lovers and Tranquillity
With 365 beaches, Antigua is a dream for travellers who want peace, quiet, and Caribbean simplicity. The island is dotted with intimate, stylish all-inclusive properties that focus on relaxation.
Why choose Antigua:
• Soft sand beaches around the entire coastline
• Excellent boutique all-inclusive resorts
• Calm waters ideal for swimming and snorkelling
• Low-rise hotels and a peaceful atmosphere
Antigua is perfect for travellers who want a slow, serene Caribbean break with lots of beachfront time.
Grenada: For Food Lovers and Authentic Caribbean Charm
Grenada, known as the Spice Island, offers a characterful blend of beaches, rainforest, and an emerging scene of premium boutique resorts. It’s quieter and less developed than some islands, making it ideal for travellers wanting deeper cultural immersion.
Why choose Grenada:
• Beautiful, uncrowded beaches including Grand Anse
• Farm-to-table cuisine and excellent rum
• Unique experiences such as waterfalls and chocolate plantations
• A smaller, authentic Caribbean island feel
Grenada suits food lovers, nature lovers, and travellers who prefer a slower pace.
Dominican Republic: For Great Value and Resort Variety
The Dominican Republic is home to some of the Caribbean’s largest all-inclusive resorts, offering exceptional value with wide-ranging entertainment, large pools, and beachfront activities.
Why choose the Dominican Republic:
• Excellent pricing for all-inclusive packages
• Huge resort complexes ideal for families
• White sand beaches in Punta Cana and La Romana
• Consistent weather and plenty of flight options
Travellers looking for affordability without compromising weather or beach quality will find the Dominican Republic appealing.
Aruba, Curaçao, and Bonaire (ABC Islands): For Reliable Weather and Unique Culture
The Dutch Caribbean islands sit outside the hurricane belt, offering year-round sunshine, colourful architecture, and some of the Caribbean’s best snorkelling and diving.
Why choose the ABC Islands:
• Minimal hurricane risk
• Strong European influence and vibrant culture
• Fantastic food scenes
• Great for island-hopping between the three islands
These islands attract travellers who want reliable weather, boutique resorts, and a culturally diverse Caribbean experience.
Which Caribbean Island Is Best for...
Couples
• St Lucia
• Barbados
• Antigua
These islands offer intimate, adult-focused resorts and plenty of romantic experiences.
Families
• Dominican Republic
• Barbados
• Jamaica
Large resort facilities, kids’ clubs, and calm beaches make these perfect for family holidays.
Luxury Travellers
• Barbados
• St Lucia
• Antigua
These destinations offer the Caribbean’s most elegant all-inclusive properties.
Adventure Travellers
• St Lucia
• Grenada
• Dominica
Mountains, waterfalls, rainforest, and volcanic landscapes offer endless exploration opportunities.
Beach Lovers
• Antigua
• Barbados
• Aruba
These islands are known for long stretches of clear water, soft sand, and dreamy coastlines.
Best Time of Year for Caribbean All-Inclusive Holidays
The Caribbean is a year-round destination, but choosing the right time depends on your priorities.
Dry season (December to April):
• Best weather
• Low humidity
• Peak prices
Shoulder season (May to early June, late November):
• Excellent value
• Fewer crowds
• Warm temperatures
Low season (June to October):
• Best prices for packages and flights
• Mixed weather and chance of storms
• Great for flexible travellers
Travellers booking all-inclusive holidays during shoulder season often find the best balance of weather, value, and availability.
How Newmont Travel Helps You Choose the Best Island
With more than 60 years of heritage serving UK travellers and the Caribbean diaspora, Newmont Travel offers expert guidance that goes far deeper than standard holiday search engines.
Travellers benefit from:
• Personal service
• Caribbean-specific knowledge
• Advice on which island suits your travel style
• Tailored all-inclusive packages
• Flexible deposits and payment plans
• ATOL protection
• Handpicked resorts matched to your needs
Whether you want relaxation, culture, adventure, or family-friendly entertainment, Newmont ensures your Caribbean holiday is shaped around you.
Frequently Asked Questions: Caribbean All-Inclusive Holidays
Which Caribbean island is best for an all-inclusive holiday?
The best island depends on your travel style. Barbados offers refined luxury and culture, St Lucia is ideal for romance and scenery, Jamaica provides exceptional value and vibrant experiences, and Antigua is perfect for beach lovers. Families often prefer the Dominican Republic or Jamaica due to larger resorts and kid-friendly facilities.
Which Caribbean island has the best weather for an all-inclusive holiday?
Aruba, Bonaire, and Curaçao (the ABC Islands) have the most reliable weather as they sit outside the hurricane belt. Barbados also has consistently stable conditions. These destinations are ideal for travellers who want year-round sunshine with minimal seasonal disruption.
What is the cheapest Caribbean island for all-inclusive resorts?
The Dominican Republic is usually the most affordable all-inclusive destination, with large resort complexes and excellent value packages. Jamaica is another strong option for cost-effective holidays without sacrificing beach quality or cultural experiences.
Is an all-inclusive holiday worth it in the Caribbean?
Yes. For most travellers, an all-inclusive package provides exceptional value because meals, drinks, activities, and entertainment are included. It also helps with budgeting, especially for families or groups. If you plan to spend most of your time relaxing by the pool or beach, the cost savings can be significant.
When is the best time to book an all-inclusive holiday in the Caribbean?
Booking 6–9 months in advance is recommended for peak-season travel between December and April. Shoulder seasons such as May, early June, and late November offer excellent value with fewer crowds. For the lowest prices, consider travelling between June and October, although this is also hurricane season in some islands.
Which Caribbean islands are best for families?
The Dominican Republic, Jamaica, and Barbados are excellent for families thanks to their spacious all-inclusive resorts, kids’ clubs, calm waters, and diverse activities. These islands offer family-friendly dining, entertainment, and convenient flight connections.
Which Caribbean islands are best for couples?
St Lucia, Barbados, and Antigua offer romantic, boutique-style all-inclusive resorts with private beaches, exceptional dining, and peaceful environments. Many properties cater specifically to honeymooners and adults-only travellers.
Are all-inclusive holidays in the Caribbean good for adventure seekers?
Yes. Islands like St Lucia, Grenada, and Dominica are perfect for travellers wanting more than beaches. They offer hiking, waterfalls, volcanic springs, rainforest zip-lining, diving, and sailing excursions. Many all-inclusive resorts provide guided tours and adventure packages.
Do all-inclusive resorts include flights to the Caribbean?
Packages booked through Newmont Travel can include flights, transfers, accommodation, meals, beverages, and activities. Booking flights and hotels together ensures better pricing and ATOL protection.
Is it safe to travel to the Caribbean for an all-inclusive holiday?
The majority of Caribbean destinations are safe for tourists, particularly within resort areas. Newmont Travel provides island-specific advice, trusted hotel recommendations, and guidance on where to stay for maximum comfort and security.
Which Caribbean islands have the most luxury all-inclusive resorts?
Barbados, St Lucia, Antigua, and Grenada each offer high-end, private, luxury all-inclusive properties known for premium dining, personalised service, and exclusive beachfront locations.
Are Caribbean all-inclusive holidays good value for money?
Yes. When meals, drinks, entertainment, and activities are included, travellers often find that all-inclusive packages deliver better overall value compared with paying for everything separately. This is especially true for families and couples travelling during shoulder seasons.